Harmonix’s decision to not launch the Xbox 360 version ofRock Band 2with instruments was a curious one, but understandable. The thinking is that with the original instruments completely compatible with the full game — and so many of them already in gamers’ homes — offering it up as a bundle on day one wasn’t necessarily a priority.
Instead, those who already have the instruments can pick up the standalone version ofRock Band 2. And those who are getting in to the game for the first time can now pick and choose their hardware from the new wireless guitar and wireless drum set, both of which are available for standalone purchase.
But what about everyone who already has a drum set and a plastic guitar or two (or three or seven) in their home? Are the newRock Band 2instruments worth it? After a few weeks of fairly heavy use, I’ve compiled some information that might help you out with your decision.
[Note: If you’re looking for our review of theRock Band 2game,that can be found here.]
The good:
The “meh”:
Verdict:The guitar is improved for sure, but not nearly enough to necessarily justify a purchase. If you still have the original wired guitar and you like it, this is a good alternative if you’re tired of dealing with cords. If you’re fine with what you have, there’s no need to spend $69.99 on a new peripheral. The auto-calibration is a nice feature, but not completely necessary considering you may only use it once to calibrate your set. And if you hated the original, you may appreciate the slightly improved strum bar, but it likely won’t change your mind.
The verdict:The kit looks pretty much the same on the outside, but is definitely improved overall. The fact that it’s wireless and more sturdy is a good reason to upgrade. Unlike guitars, stores like GameStop won’t buy back your used drums, so you’ll have to take a loss or sell your old kit on Ebay or Craiglists. There’s always the option of keeping both sets and staging some eviction-inducing head-to-head drum battles.
